In Uncertain Times, Does Sustainability Matter?
In this blog, we explore how brands across North America can turn consumer concern for the environment into a strategic advantage, even during economic uncertainty.
Economic uncertainty often forces brands to scrutinize every marketing investment. Yet recent IMI Pulse© data shows that 89% of Canadians and 86% of Americans remain concerned about environmental issues, ranking it fifth among top concerns after money/economy, health, social issues, and digital/technology. The question isn't whether sustainability matters, it's whether brands understand how to leverage environmental messaging strategically during challenging times.
The measurement challenge most brands face
Many companies treat sustainability as a checkbox exercise rather than a strategic brand differentiator. They assume environmental messaging appeals universally or abandon it entirely during economic downturns. Through IMI's 50+ years of consumer research, we've found this binary thinking misses the real opportunity: Sustainability functions as a tie-breaker in purchase decisions when positioned strategically and done authentically.
Traditional approaches fail because they don't segment audiences effectively or integrate environmental benefits into the broader value equation. Our methodology shows that successful brands treat sustainability like any other brand attribute - understanding which consumers care most and how environmental benefits drive motivation within their specific category context without forcing trade-offs.
The strategic framework for environmental positioning
IMI Pulse© data reveals that sustainability works as a purchase driver, but never in isolation. 52% of total consumers say they buy products because they are environmentally friendly, yet they simultaneously weigh this factor against price, convenience, and brand trust. The challenge for brands isn't just offering sustainable options - it's ensuring sustainability enhances rather than competes with other key purchase drivers.
Generational segmentation drives activation rates
While overall environmental concern runs high, behaviour varies significantly by age group. Millennials lead at 62% factoring sustainability into purchase decisions, followed by Gen Z at 56%. This compares to the broader data showing 57% of Millennials and 54% of Gen Z actively purchase products supporting sustainability. The consistency across our research confirms environmental messaging resonates most when targeting younger demographics who translate concern into action.
Geographic nuances require localized strategies
Regional differences create distinct opportunities. Our data shows 64% of Mexican consumers prioritize sustainable purchases compared to 49% of Americans and 42% of Canadians. Additionally, 54% of North Americans purchase products specifically because they are environmentally friendly - 50% of Canadians and 54% of Americans. For brands operating across North American markets, this geographic variation suggests tailored messaging strategies, and ‘environmentally friendly’ may be a more broadly appealing communication benefit.
Understanding sustainability as a trade-off factor
IMI Pulse© research confirms that sustainability competes with price and promotion. While many consumers prefer sustainable products, they may still opt for lower-cost alternatives if the price gap is significant. Similarly, convenience can outweigh sustainability, if an environmentally friendly product requires extra effort to find, consumers may choose more accessible alternatives.
Integration with core value propositions amplifies impact
The most effective sustainability campaigns don't lead with environmental benefits alone. Through analyzing successful approaches, we've found that brands achieve good results when environmental advantages reinforce primary purchase drivers - quality, performance, or value - rather than functioning as standalone selling propositions.
Framework application: Making sustainability work without trade-offs
Consider how successful brands leverage these insights strategically. Companies targeting Millennials and Gen Z integrate environmental benefits prominently, knowing these segments actively seek sustainable options. However, they frame sustainability as added value rather than a feature requiring compromise.
Effective brands align sustainability with other key purchase drivers. A personal care company emphasizes that sustainable packaging delivers the same durability and effectiveness as traditional materials. A food brand highlighting locally sourced ingredients promotes both freshness and environmental benefits to reinforce purchase intent.
Trust and credibility prove crucial in this framework. Consumers remain skeptical of greenwashing, so brands must clearly communicate what makes products sustainable and why it matters. A clothing brand using recycled materials should highlight both eco-friendliness and impact reduction specifics.
Implementation roadmap for strategic environmental marketing
Start by segmenting your audience using our generational and geographic data to identify high-potential segments. Millennials at 62% and Gen Z at 56% represent your primary targets for sustainability messaging, but the pathway to reaching them requires integration with other purchase drivers.
Next, audit your category context and position sustainability benefits to complement rather than replace your core value proposition. Make sustainability an additional benefit that doesn't force consumers to compromise on price, quality, or convenience.
Test messaging that leverages sustainability as a differentiator in close decisions. When two products are similar in price and quality, environmental benefits can be the deciding factor—but only when integrated thoughtfully with existing brand strengths.
Enhance trust through transparency. Our methodology shows integrated approaches deliver better business impact when brands clearly communicate the authenticity of their sustainability efforts rather than making generic environmental claims.
The proven path forward
IMI's 50+ years of experience measuring consumer behaviour, including recent IMI Pulse© findings, confirms that sustainability marketing works - when applied strategically. Environmental messaging creates differentiation for brands that understand their audiences and category dynamics while recognizing that sustainability exists alongside price, convenience, and trust in consumer decision-making.
Through our global network of 150+ partners across 45+ countries, we've helped brands navigate exactly these positioning challenges with our proven measurement methodologies. The key lies in treating environmental benefits as strategic brand assets that enhance, rather than compete, with other purchase drivers.
Ready to understand how environmental positioning can drive growth for your specific market and audience? Contact us to learn how our measurement expertise can help you position your environmental products or brand to drive motivation and growth for your business, backed by our comprehensive guarantee.
Stay Ahead with Marketing Insights That Matter
Get exclusive access to thought leadership, case studies, and actionable insights that help you stay on the cutting edge of marketing excellence.